May Truck Sales Fall 19.5%

Analysts Say Class 8 Downturn Not Over Yet

This story appears in the June 20 print edition of Transport Topics.

U.S. retail sales of Class 8 trucks in May dropped 19.5% as the downturn rolled on for a sixth consecutive month and still has not hit bottom, analysts said.

Sales fell to 17,312 units compared with 21,501 a year earlier, WardsAuto.com reported. May was the latest month in a year-over-year slide that began in December 2015 鈥 after increases in 26 of the previous 27 months.

鈥淢aybe the story is about what we already know,鈥 Steve Tam, vice president, commercial vehicle sector at ACT Research Co., told Transport Topics, referring to the glut of inventory and other factors that are stifling sales growth.



Year-to-date, Class 8 sales fell 12.3% to 85,804 compared with 97,819 in the 2015 period.

The 248,804 sales in 2015 marked the third-highest total since 2000, according to Ward鈥檚.

Tam said ACT recently lowered its North American Class 8 production forecast for 2016 to 236,000 units, a decrease of 500. It also adjusted its outlook for 2017 to 214,300 from 245,100 and for 2018 to 260,700 from 274,700.

鈥淲e are starting to see less momentum than we had previously seen,鈥 he said. 鈥淪o this ends up being a multiyear downturn as opposed to just a one-year trough. We are all sitting around waiting for freight to start flowing in a positive fashion again, and that is just not happening.鈥

In May, Freightliner continued as the market leader, although it saw double-digit declines, as did all other truck manufacturers except Western Star.

Freightliner鈥檚 sales fell 15% to 7,012 trucks, earning it a 40.5% market share. Western Star sold 463, a gain of 72, for a 2.7% share. Freightliner and Western Star are units of Daimler Trucks North America.

鈥淵ou have come from a banner peak year in 2015 and come off it faster than people anticipated. My contention was it was never as good as it seemed,鈥 said Don Ake, vice president of commercial vehicles at research firm FTR. 鈥淭he big question is now 2017. There is concern in the marketplace that things have not stabilized.鈥

Ake said excess Class 8 inventory is in the range of 15,000 to 20,000 trucks, 鈥渁nd they are not moving out.鈥

He said the glut has spread to original equipment manufacturers in addition to their dealers.

鈥淲hat I have heard is that you鈥檝e got elevated inventories at the OEM level, too,鈥 Ake said. 鈥淭hey just overbuilt. The big fleets were telling them to crank up.

鈥淭he big fleets were overoptimistic, too. They over ordered. The OEMs overbuilt, and so now inventories remain very bloated.鈥

Asked if that was across all OEMs, he said, 鈥淕ut feel would say yes. Obviously, some companies have more excess than others.鈥

International Trucks, a unit of Navistar International Corp., saw sales drop 27.4% year-over-year to 1,743 units, good for a 10.1% market share.

Bill Kozek, president of trucks and parts for Navistar, said during a quarterly earnings call in June the company鈥檚 orders are up 2 percentage points year-over-year.

鈥淪o that鈥檚 reason to anticipate share growth in the second half,鈥 Kozek said. 鈥淲e鈥檙e down 1% in retail year-over-year in the heavy segment, and that鈥檚 predominantly due to some of our larger over-the-road and leasing customers not buying the amounts or the volumes that we had forecast for 2016.鈥

Volvo Trucks North America saw sales drop the most, plunging 36.6% to 1,775 units, good for a 10.3% share of the market.

鈥淲hile we still anticipate a solid overall Class 8 market in 2016,鈥 lower freight volumes, weaker manufacturing and high inventories across the economy 鈥渞educed demand in longhaul, a core segment for Volvo Trucks,鈥 said Magnus Koeck, vice president for marketing.

Sales at Mack Trucks dropped 15% to 1,376, good for a 7.9% market share.

鈥淓xcess inventories throughout the economy [are] resulting in a drag on Class 8 retail sales,鈥 said John Walsh, Mack vice president of global marketing. 鈥淭he construction sector remains a relative bright spot, which is good news for Mack,鈥 citing the Granite model.

VTNA and Mack are units of Volvo Group.

At Kenworth Truck Co. sales fell 17.6% to 2,587, good for a 14.9% market share. Sales at Peterbilt Motors Co. were 2,347, down 18.9%, earning it a 13.6% share.

Kenworth and Peterbilt are units of Paccar Inc.

Michael Baudendistel, an analyst with Stifel, Nicolaus & Co., wrote in a note to investors this month, 鈥淲e believe a pre-buy ahead of the 2021 Environmental Protection Agency [greenhouse-gas] regulations could lead to strong demand for trucks in 2019-2020.鈥

Other truck manufacturers were unavailable for comment.